Welcome to

The Cheesecake Fairy

Landing soon to a fine establishment near you!  The Cheesecake Fairy creates upscale “one of a kind” sweet and savory cheesecakes in a jar for bakeries, restaurants, cafes, and charitable organizations throughout Southwestern, PA. 


Jennifer Melnick Carota

Our leader and chief cheesecake artist comes from a long line of seasoned bakers. She caught the baking bug while helping her Granny Rose make her famous chicken pot pies in her home kitchen. Now licensed and fully certified, Jennifer creates exclusive cheesecakes for upscale eateries, events and private affairs in the Pittsburgh, PA region. Each cheesecake is a piece of art that you will be proud to serve. Indulge in the magic of every bite!

One Of A Kind


Each and every one of our cheesecake collaborations yields an exclusive and memorable one of a kind recipe!  If you would like to work together to create the perfect cheesecake for you, please contact me. Let’s make magic together!

Strawberry Pie

Strawberries, Vanilla Cheesecake, Flakey Pie Crust

In partnership with Valdiserri’s Bakery.


Boozy Fruit, Vanilla Cheesecake, Golden Vanilla Butter Cake

In partnership with J&D Cellars Winery.

Peach Bellini

Boozy Fruit, Vanilla Cheesecake, Golden Vanilla Butter Cake

In partnership with J&D Cellars Winery.

Whiskey Cream

Vanilla Cheesecake infused with Whiskey Cream by Liberty Pole Spirits

In partnership with the Marketplace at Emerald Valley,

Hot Chocolate & Vanilla Winter Bliss

Social media flavor naming contest for seasonal cheesecake selection in the Sweete Shop

In partnership with Overly’s Country Christmas.


Vanilla Cheesecake, Toasted Nuts, Cinnamon Honey,  Puffed Pastry

In partnership with By George.

Drooling yet? Read our rave


Not only do we have fans, we have fanatics!  See what our customers are raving about.

Heritage Craft Butchers has been carrying The Cheesecake Fairy’s product for months and we are delighted with them. Every flavor we’ve received has been high quality and distinct. The product itself is compact and easy to vend. It’s compact, easy to store, easy to sell, and above all, it tastes fantastic. Jennifer’s enthusiasm for her business is apparent and her taste is impeccable both in flavor and aesthetic. I can’t think of a better item for retailers to stock… local, high quality, and always in demand.

– Bob Von Scio, Heritage Craft Butchers

Oh, my YUM! These tasty treats are small and satisfying. They make a perfect treat for a buffet, or a gift for your favorite friend, family member or client. Very high quality and delicious.

Beth Caldwell, Pittsburgh Professional Women

On behalf of Country Store Cafe, I can say with absolute confidence what a pleasure & honor to have partnered with The Cheesecake Fairy on many business projects! The integrity, love & passion that goes into each cheesecake creation is truly commendable!

Tina Theys, The Country Store

Want to collaborate? We offer 


Are you looking to elevate your menu or merchandizing to another level? Let’s make magic together…allow us to collectively create a unique cheesecake just for you!  

The Cheesecake Fairy is Seeking Partnerships with…

  • Restaurants, Café’s, Wineries
  • Gourmet Grocery and Retail Outlets
  • Subscription “Box” vendors including local CSA’s and prepared meal delivery

Consider adding Cheesecake Fairy Jars…

  • To your seasonal menu
  • In your subscription “gift box or bag” service
  • On your food delivery menu (cheesecake jars are perfectly portable!)
  • For your next Special Occasion or Special Event

Why Choose Cheesecake Fairy Cheesecake Jars?  

  • Perfectly portioned, easy to serve
  • Freezer friendly for up to six months
  • Easily portable for “take out” or family meals to “to go”
  • Easy to upsell 
  • Made with locally sourced “farm to table” ingredients when possible
Let’s Talk

Treat Yourself

Contact Us

We’d love to work with you!  Contact us for more information…

    Call Us

    (724) 268-0282

    Store Locator

    Find A Jar Near You

    The Cheesecake Fairy provides custom curated cheesecake flavors to various food vendors throughout the Pittsburgh Region.  Please contact the establishments below to confirm flavors and availability.

    Valdiserri’s Bakery
    Belle Vernon, PA 724-929-8040

    J&D Cellars at the Street at the Meadows
    Washington, PA | 

    Heritage Craft Butchers
    Waynesburg, PA  |  Marianna, PA 724-751-2096

    Get Social